MMU student in girlfriend’s murder case declared unfit to stand trial, court orders re-evaluation

In a report filed in court, Mathari National Teaching and Referral Hospital concluded that Mutinda is mentally unstable following a psychiatric evaluation.
A mental assessment report has found that Eric Mutinda, a Multimedia University of Kenya (MMU) student and the prime suspect in the murder of his girlfriend, Sylvia Kemunto, is mentally unfit to stand trial.
In a report filed in court, Mathari National Teaching and Referral Hospital says that after evaluation, they concluded that Mutinda is unstable.
More To Read
- Janet Waiyaki case: Two police officers found guilty of causing grievous harm to driver
- Court of Appeal upholds Sh10 million compensation to widow of Pakistani journalist killed in Kenya
- Cop charged with killing colleague during Gigiri bar fight to stand trial in February 2026
- Court to rule on bail for OCS Taalam, five others accused of killing blogger Albert Ojwang
- Two police constables sentenced to 35 years for torturing, killing suspect in 2020
- Today's court cases: Nairobi court to rule on MP Kihara case as Rex Masai, Charles Were trials resume
According to the report, the first-year Multimedia University student was found to be mentally unstable.
Mutinda, who appeared without a relative to provide corroborative history, denied committing the offence but acknowledged that he had been charged with murder.
The Mathari Hospital psychiatrist noted that he was fairly groomed and cooperative with difficulty, but his speech was low in tone and pitch, and his history was considered unreliable.
"He is not fit to plead and recommended further corroborative history from his next of kin to complete the evaluation", the report indicates.
However, Kibera High Court Judge Diana Kavedza ordered the Prisons Department to return Mutinda to Mathari Hospital for a re-evaluation, this time accompanied by a relative to provide corroborative background information, despite the initial report.
Mutinda had initially pleaded not guilty, prompting the court to order a psychiatric evaluation to assess his mental fitness to stand trial.
The court is expected to receive the updated mental report before deciding on how the case will proceed.
Top Stories Today